clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile
Sunderland v Blackburn Rovers - Sky Bet Championship

Filed under:

Ellis Simms’ departure is a blow for Sunderland, but it’s not a season-defining moment

As Simms returns to Everton, all thoughts now turn to the upcoming transfer window and how we might successfully replace him, writes Phil West

Photo by Lee Parker - CameraSport via Getty Images

When the news of Ellis Simms’ sudden recall to Everton broke late on Friday night before being officially confirmed on Saturday morning, it was greeted with a mixture of frustration and concern from many Sunderland fans- not least because it meant that he’d be unavailable for tomorrow’s trip to Blackpool.

After a promising loan spell on Wearside, during which time he scored seven league goals and often dovetailed effectively with Ross Stewart, the young striker is on his way back to Merseyside as Frank Lampard desperately seeks attacking reinforcements in order to keep the Toffees afloat.

Sunderland v Blackburn Rovers - Sky Bet Championship Photo by Lee Parker - CameraSport via Getty Images

The upshot is that for now, we’ve been left with one frontline striker in Stewart, and January’s transfer demands have been brought into even sharper focus.

Personally, I’m sad to see him leave, because I’m a huge fan of Simms.

Despite criticisms of his playing style (certainly in comparison to the explosive Stewart) and some rather distasteful remarks about whether he feigned injury at Reading, he added value to our attack during his time in red and white. Crucially, he also provided us with some much-needed depth behind the big Scot.

There’s no ill will towards Everton regarding the end of his loan spell, although I do worry that pitching Simms into a relegation battle at Goodison Park may not be as conducive to his development as his time on Wearside, but only time will tell.

Wigan Athletic v Sunderland - Sky Bet Championship Photo by Ian Horrocks/Sunderland AFC via Getty Images

One major positive is that Simms has departed right at the start of the window, leaving us with ample time to replace him. This means that we should avoid a last-ditch scramble, which has often been the case in years gone by.

It’s imperative, therefore, that there’s no element of panic from the club hierarchy, and I don’t believe there will be.

If Kristjaan Speakman and Stuart Harvey have learned the lessons from last January, and the saga of Jermain Defoe’s return, they’ll have had targets in mind for some time and will’ve laid the groundwork to secure their services as swiftly and efficiently as possible.

Forward planning is key, and Speakman’s statement, during which he expressed his gratitude for Simms’ efforts, was as diplomatic as you would expect. Indeed, the situation simply highlights the double-edged sword of loan deals, but it’s fair to say that we’ve certainly benefited from his time here.

Quite how this affects Stewart’s contractual situation, and the urgency to renew his deal, is unknown, but the demands to ‘give him what he wants’ are only likely to grow louder.

For now, as attention turns to potential arrivals, and with names such as Aston Villa’s Cameron Archer being bandied around, could Nathan Broadhead be a viable option?

Sheffield Wednesday v Sunderland - Sky Bet League One Play-Off Semi Final 2nd Leg Photo by Mark Fletcher/MI News/NurPhoto via Getty Images

Yes, there’s been plenty of fallout from his decision to choose Wigan over us last summer, but it feels like there’s an element of unfinished business at Sunderland for the Welshman, and within our current system, he’d surely be able to contribute with goals and assists.

Injury worries persist with Broadhead, but there’s no doubt in my mind that his ability is being wasted at the DW Stadium, even if he moved there for his own sound reasons.

When they visited the Stadium of Light earlier in the season, he barely got a kick, and on Thursday night, he didn’t even get off the bench. That’s simply not a good place to be for a player of his undoubted talent, and I think that he’d relish the chance to have another crack in the red and white stripes.

However, if we didn’t bring him back, who’s to say that the club won’t come up trumps and secure the services of another forward who can contribute as impressively as Simms did?

Losing the young striker is a blow, without a doubt, but it’s not a season-defining moment.

There’s no reason to lose faith in our chances of replacing him, and by the end of next month, I’m confident that our attacking options will be as exciting and as plentiful as they were during his final game for us, as we cruised past the Latics 4-1 on Thursday evening.


Editorial: Haway man Lads, let’s see a bit of fight!


Fan Letters: “Kyril Louis Dreyfus needs to change the plan or sell the club”


Sunderland are repeating past mistakes with their mismanagement of Jobe

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the Roker Report Daily Roundup newsletter!

A daily roundup of Sunderland news from Roker Report