clock menu more-arrow no yes
Rotherham United v Sunderland - Sky Bet League One

Filed under:

Starting XI: Is this the Sunderland side that will take on Sheffield Wednesday this evening?

Sunderland are in need of a win at Hillsborough to end our run of back-to-back defeats in League One. We have a go at guessing the starting XI – what do you reckon?

Photo by Ian Horrocks/Sunderland AFC via Getty Images

Despite a good performance last midweek against championship QPR, Sunderland came crashing back down to earth by putting in our worse display of the campaign so far in Saturday’s five—one defeat at the New York Stadium.

The return of Leon Dajaku, Lynden Gooch, Corey Evans and Elliot Embleton to selection over the last week should have aided Sunderland’s cause, but instead, we can expect a few more changes for tonight’s game following such a poor showing.

Aiden McGeady was sent off for a silly second yellow with his side three-one down at Rotherham, so he will join Denver Hume, Nathan Broadhead, Arbenit Xhemajli, Niall Huggins and Jordan Willis in being unavailable for tonight’s match.

Here’s how I think the Lads will line up.


GK: Hoffmann

Despite impressing overall since his arrival from Bayern Munich at the end of the January transfer window, Thorben Hoffmann has now conceded more than four goals in a game twice this season, and that is a stat that could affect the confidence of a young goalkeeper.

The German stopper cannot take much of the blame for the goals we conceded at Pompey, nor can he be blamed for our overall poor performance at the weekend, but he made a glaring error for the home side’s fifth and final goal of the afternoon.

He’ll probably start again tonight, but if he was in any other position on the field you’d probably take the youngster out of the limelight for a game or two. Hopefully, Lee Johnson won’t be wishing he had done that for his goalkeeper after tonight’s match.

Rotherham United v Sunderland - Sky Bet League One Photo by Ian Horrocks/Sunderland AFC via Getty Images

CB: Flanagan CB: Wright CB: Doyle

I wrote in this weekend’s edition of Talking Tactics about how Sunderland have struggled against sides that use a 3-5-2 formation this season, so guess which shape tonight’s opponents use!

Lee Johnson does have a number of options at centre-half, if he decides the Luke O’Nien midfield experiment is over he can be added to natural centre defenders Bailey Wright and Frederick Alves as options to come into the side.

Tom Flanagan and Callum Doyle probably have enough credit in the bank to keep their places in the side despite Saturday’s result, and with both players suiting the wide-centre-back roles I think we’ll see Bailey Wright return to the middle of a back three - the position in which we’ve seen him play his best football in red and white.

Rotherham United v Sunderland - Sky Bet League One Photo by Ian Horrocks/Sunderland AFC via Getty Images

RM: Gooch CM: Winchester CM: Neil LM: Cirkin

If Sunderland do switch to a three man defence for tonight's game, it will be interesting to see who makes up the midfield four or five.

Lynden Gooch and Dennis Cirkin are both guaranteed to start at wing back, with both players the first (and only) choices in those positions if we use a back five.

In the middle, Carl Winchester's energy from right back could be useful in a two-man midfield and his performances at fullback deserve to be rewarded with a stint in his natural position.

Although a combination of Winchester and Neil could be considered too attacking in a 4-2-3-1 or 4-2-2-2 system, with three centre backs to cover the pair do have the potential to offer both box to box running and an eye for a pass.

Rotherham United v Sunderland - Sky Bet League One Photo by Ian Horrocks/Sunderland AFC via Getty Images

AM: Embleton AM: Pritchard ST: Stewart

Aiden McGeady's absence means that there'll be at least one change in attaching areas from the four forwards that started down at Rotherham.

With Lynden Gooch possibly playing at full back, the leaves Elliot Embleton, Alex Pritchard, Leon Dajaku and Aiden O'Brien to fill the remaining two places behind Ross Stewart.

Leon Dajaku's performances as a starter probably indicate he's best used off the bench, so that leaves Lee Johnson to either 'stick' and choose the reliable Aiden O'Brien or 'twist' and pick both Embleton and Pritchard.

I'd be tempted to go for the latter option, in the knowledge that the switch to a back three would hopefully solidify the side enough for the two number tens to play narrow and close to Ross Stewart.

Rotherham United v Sunderland - Sky Bet League One Photo by Ian Horrocks/Sunderland AFC via Getty Images
REPORT & PLAYER RATINGS!

Finlay’s Report: ‘Yet again’... an all too familiar tale for Sunderland against Oxford

OPINION!

Talking Points: Good performance - but is a point enough? And... can we just calm down a bit?

SAFC QUIZZES!

Roker Report’s Brainbusters: Time to get stuck into the latest set of Sunderland quiz questions!