clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Who is Sam Brotherton? We put SAFC's New Zealand international defender under the microscope

Some Sunderland supporters might not be completely aware of this but one of our own has been out with his country at the Confederations Cup this summer.

New Zealand v Ukraine: Group A - FIFA U-20 World Cup New Zealand 2015 Photo by Martin Hunter/Getty Images

Full Name: Samuel Edward Brotherton

Date & Place of Birth: 2nd October 1996 (age 20) in Auckland, NZ

Previous Clubs: Wisconsin Badgers, Wanderers SC, Des Moines Menace

International Record: New Zealand - 7 caps, 0 goals


Sam Brotherton, a New Zealand international, was signed at the end of the January transfer window and has been eased into life on Wearside, featuring only a handful of times for our U23s before the completion of last season.

There's certainly a sense of intrigue when it comes to Brotherton, at least from myself, as it's not often that we'd sign a full international to make up a part of our youth team. Should we expect him to play a bigger role in our side next season, or should we not let the fact that he has played for his country misguide our judgement of him?

Portugal v New Zealand: Round of 16 - FIFA U-20 World Cup New Zealand 2015
Brotherton takes on Andre Silva of Portugal, a player that has just signed for Italian giants AC Milan for a fee of around €38m.
Photo by Hannah Peters/Getty Images

In truth, I'd be lying if I said I knew a great deal about Brotherton. So, with that in mind, I thought I'd collar someone that knows him a little better in order to give us some clearer perspective on what we can expect from the New Zealander.

Step forward Dave Webster, a blogger who has a keen interest in all things New Zealand and football. I sat down with Dave to talk specifically about Brotherton, and whether or not he feels that the Sunderland defender is capable of becoming a success here on Wearside.


RR: So - Sam Brotherton. What can you tell Sunderland fans about his career path so far that our supporters might not know much about already?

DW: Brotherton started his career at Wanderers SC (SC stands for Special Club). Wanderers was an U20 development team that competed in the NZ National League and National Youth League, with the aim of developing players and a team to compete in the 2015 U20 World Cup which was held in NZ. He played every game (16) and scored 1 goal in the National League. He has represented NZ at U20, U23 and full international level.

He then went on to study in the United States at the University of Wisconsin, which is where he played before arriving at Sunderland.

RR: What type of defender is Sam, and do you feel he's suited for English football?

DW: He is a leader on the pitch, strong in the air and confident on the ball. There is a large British influence throughout NZ Football, through expats living here and newer arrivals. Brotherton's manager at Wanderers SC was ex-Watford player Darren Bazeley, so I think he will have no problem adjusting to playing in England.

RR: He came to the club from the United States, where he played for The University of Wisconsin. Whilst he's inexperienced at club level there may be some expectancy for him to play a part for Sunderland next season in the Championship. How confident are you that he'd be able to succeed in our first team next season?

DW: He has developed a huge amount since he has been at the University of Wisconsin and he has a strong mental capability. Having NZ U20 keeper Michael Would around as well will help. It's always hard to predict how certain players will go, a few years ago Sunderland signed Jack Pelter, who was tipped to go on to bigger things but it never worked out. Although, I think Brotherton with his International experience will do well.

RR: As I noted earlier Sam is a full international with New Zealand and has been away with the national team at the Confederations Cup over the past few weeks. That said, he wasn't afforded any game time in Russia and you can only hope that he'll have gained vital experience from just being at the tournament. Why do you feel he has been unable to break into the side?

DW: He is still only 20 and was the second youngest of the defenders that we took to Russia. All the other defenders we took are playing regular club football in the 1st or 2nd tier, Brotherton was the only one who wasn't and was there as a backup option and to gain some experience for the future.

RR: What about the broader question of young players from New Zealand - is there a spring of talents coming through ready to be tapped up by European clubs?

DW: New Zealand is awash with academies (which may or may not be a good thing, but that's another debate) and there is some talent there, however the step up from New Zealand to even the A-League in Australia is a large one and it is questionable whether a lot of these players have the right attitude to succeed in Europe. The pathway for NZ youth these days seems to be, like the one Brotherton has taken, via Universities in the United States.

RR: Just to round off, what is the expectancy in New Zealand for Brotherton's future - do people think he's capable of becoming a huge success on a big stage?

DW: Probably not, but that is more of a reflection of Kiwi's attitudes and low expectations when it comes to football and footballers going overseas than of Brotherton as a player. There are a lot of Kiwi's who go overseas but only a couple have had huge success on a big stage such as Wynton Rufer, Ryan Nelsen, Winston Reid and you could possibly add Chris Wood to that list after last season. Everyone will be hoping he does well but there are unlikely to be any great expectations that he will go on to be a huge success.


Thanks to Dave for helping us out. If you're interested in hearing more from him be sure to check out his blog by clicking here, and his twitter by clicking here.